Outside magazine recently published a story about Cold Water Immersion Stages and Survival Tips. The article reminded me about an experience I had as a college student when I was working for the National Park Concessionaire on Isle Royale, an island in Lake Superior.
I was a waitress at Rock Harbor Lodge during the summers of 1983-84. The lodge is one of the only civilized spots on the wilderness island, which has no roads or other amenities. Instead, it’s filled with wolves, moose, loons, and fog. Lake trout swim in the depths, hikers tread the challenging trails, and boaters brave the waves.
I think it was during my first summer when I was working dinner service on a hot day. Hot on Isle Royale is a relative term. In Florida, eighty-five degrees would seem like nothing, but on “the Rock” as we called the island, it’s a heat wave. Add in a hot kitchen and the effort of serving a lot of hungry patrons, and you have a bunch of waiters, waitresses, and cooks who are sweating through their white polyester uniforms.

Outside the dining room windows, a view of the marina, with docks, sailboats, and the allure of Lake Superior’s cool blue waters beckoned. Everyone working that evening made a pact to jump off the end of the nearest dock once our shift ended.
Normally, I liked to ease into the lake slowly. I’d swum in the lake many times in a different, more sheltered, harbor nearby (Tobin Harbor). But I was young, reckless, and hot, so I joined my coworkers in the plan. I expected the water temperature to be the same as during my previous swims.
Our shift over, we all marched down the dock, fully clothed. I was perhaps the second or third person to jump into the water. The people before me whooped and hollered but had no trouble. I didn’t want to get my hair wet, so I launched myself off the high dock with arms and legs splayed to keep my head above water.
My vanity is what saved me.
As the Outside magazine story outlines about the body’s response to cold water immersion shock, the moment I hit the water, I gasped, but because my head was still above water, I gasped air instead of water. Also, both of my legs immediately cramped up, turning into useless weights that began to drag me down.
The water was frigid, much colder than I’d experienced before. What I didn’t realize was that an offshore breeze had created upwelling conditions, bringing near-freezing water up from the depths of the lake and into the harbor.
My arms still worked, so I pumped them furiously to keep afloat and to swim toward the dock. When I could catch my breath, I pleaded for help and said my legs didn’t work.
Amid all the shouting and activity of other people jumping in the water, it took a while for anyone to notice my plight. Eventually, I was able to reach the dock where two coworkers pulled me out. I don’t recall how long it took before my cramps resolved as the blood that had fled to my body’s core returned to my legs while I lay on the dock.
Thankfully, nobody else cramped up. Why me? Maybe I was also dehydrated or something. Who knows! I’m just “lucky,” I guess.
As I walked off the dock, I recall feeling grateful that I survived my cold-water plunge–grateful that I didn’t drown. Best yet, my hair didn’t get wet!
I had no other lingering effects, but I did learn one important lesson: test the water first, stupid!





































